Lucia Ristorante - New Milford, Connecticut

J W.

My husband and I had our wedding rehearsal dinner here. I was able to drop off some decor, and the wait staff did an absolutely amazing job decorating the upstairs area, which comfortably fit 35 people. It was obvious how much time and care the staff took in making the room look so special for us! The food was absolutely delicious! We had a set menu that was thoroughly explained to us. They made accommodations for those who had some diet restrictions, which made my guests very happy. There was a private entrance on the side for our guests to go straight up to the room, which was also very nice. We had family in from FL, NY, and CT, and every guest still tells us how good Lucia’s was. My husband and I come here often and we are always treated so well. Here’s some photos of our favorite dishes. Thank you again Lucia Ristorante, for such a memorable night before we said “I do”!

S B.

First time here but not our last. We sat at the bar and enjoyed the great vibe, really good authentic dishes and homemade cake for dessert. Only complaint was they were out of a couple of dishes and didn’t have the wine we ordered that was on the menu.

Jeffery J.

We had a party of five for my father-in-law‘s 83rd birthday. We didn’t realize that we had a time limit if we did we would’ve went someplace else. The chef came out and said we have to go and can’t offer you a free drink or anything because he has a big party Coming in. This is very nice to see how they treat their customers. I will never eat there again

Pizza G.

Lucia Ristorante in downtown New Milford is a gem for anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a warm, inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements the incredible food. The rustic décor, combined with a cozy, intimate setting, makes it an ideal spot for both a romantic dinner or a lively night out with friends.

But let’s talk about the food—because the Italian dishes here are truly out of this world. Lucia’s menu is packed with classic favorites, from homemade pasta to seafood dishes, and each is crafted with care and attention to detail. The flavors are rich and robust, with perfectly balanced sauces that taste like they’ve been simmering for hours. Their gnocchi melts in your mouth, and the veal parmigiana is tender and cooked to perfection. Every dish is full of fresh ingredients that transport you straight to Italy with each bite.

In addition to the fantastic food, the service is top-notch. The staff is friendly, attentive, and always ready to offer great wine pairings or menu suggestions. Whether you’re a regular or visiting for the first time, they make you feel right at home.

For delicious Italian food and a welcoming atmosphere, Lucia Ristorante is a must-visit.

Patrice

Our 1st Time Dinning at Lucia. What can I say? It was Fabulous !!! From the Owner to the Staff and the Food!! What a Wonderful Experience!! This Restorante is truly a hidden gem!

John F.

I’ve been to this restaurant a handful of times over the years. My go to dish is the Zuppa Di Pesce but since this was a lunch, I didn’t want to risk splashing fish sauce on my shirt or pants. You gotta get in there! Anyway, my friend Ant and I had a delicious lunch with a few Peronis. Our server was great and we never had to wait for the next Peroni. I’d say the star of the show was the Pistachio cake as I could have eaten five or six pieces. The room was warm and clean and looks great. They have double doors with a good sized barrier so you don’t get cold when other lunchers arrive or depart. As Homer Simpson would say…ten thumbs up!

Husang L.

So I took off 1 star for each dish I felt was subpar. Ordered a pizza to start and I haven't been more disappointed in a floppy underseasoned wet pizza. The tomatoes on the pizza were pretty much raw and just oozing water over the pizza. Flavors were disappointing and lacking. Probably could also have used another 3 minutes in the oven. The chicken Parm was probably the most disappointing thing that I've ordered though. It was soggy where the water from the chicken soaked through the breading. I had more flavor from sucking my fingers after eating celery sticks. No salt, no seasoning. Nada. The pasta that comes with the Parm was worse than spaghetti Os. I think I would have rather eaten chef boyardee. Flavorless sauce with overcooked pasta. The Fazzoletti D'Aragosta was actually good and only saving grace. The filling was flavorful and seasoned. The past was cooked correctly and the sauce complimented the dish well. Lastly, the tiramisu was... Not tiramisu? No lady fingers... Just disappointing yellow cake with the flavors of tiramisu. Dry and tasted fake. Go to big Y and get crav'n tiramisu fro the freezer section. Half the price and infinitely better. The blueberry mojito does deserve a shout out and pretty well made. Overall, I think this place needs to work on the basics of an Italian restaurant or just take it off the menu.

sengelbr

A warm, inviting Italian restuarant with a menu that does not disappoint! A surprisingly large menu that is well thought out with each dish being complex and carefully crafted. From the appetizers to the desserts (be sure to try the authentic Lemonchello!) everything is wonderfully prepared and presented by a friendly staff that cares.

It's on the smaller, more intimate side and can be slightly noisy with the hardwood and ornate ceiling, but if you need more quiet to propose to your fiancee then ask for the table overlooking the street upstairs.

At first glance it may seem a bit pricey but for the quality of the food and the experience I think it's more than worth it. If you love Italian food you'll love Lucia.